Federal employee relations work is governed by a layered framework of law and regulation. Understanding where these rules come from, how they are organized, and how they interact is foundational knowledge for any HR professional working in the federal government. Three primary sources shape this framework: the United States Code, the Code of Federal Regulations, and each agency's own internal regulations.
- The three parts of the U.S. Code most relevant to federal employment and key chapters within each
- How the Code of Federal Regulations is organized and which 5 CFR sections HR professionals need to know
- The distinction between discretionary and non-discretionary regulatory provisions
- Why agency regulations matter and what happens when an agency fails to follow its own rules
The following sections walk through each source of authority in order and highlight the specific provisions most relevant to day-to-day employee relations work.
This lesson is a preview from our Certified Federal HR Practitioner (cFHRP) Level I Certificate Program. Enroll in a course for detailed lessons, live instructor support, and project-based training.
Three titles of the U.S. Code directly govern federal employment matters.
Title 5, covering Government Organization and Employees, is the primary source of federal human resources law. Part three of Title 5, which covers the employee, contains the core HR statutes. Key chapters include Chapter 23 on merit system principles, Chapter 33 on examination, selection, and placement, which covers appointment rules, probationary periods, details, and promotions. Chapter 43 addresses performance appraisals. Chapter 45 covers incentives and awards. Chapter 61 addresses hours of work, including flexible and compressed schedules. Chapter 63 covers leave. Chapter 71 addresses labor-management relations. Chapter 75 covers adverse actions. Chapter 77 addresses appeals. Chapter 81 covers compensation for work injuries.
Title 29, the Labor title, contains federal labor laws including those addressing discrimination. Title 38 covers veterans benefits and is the source for provisions such as the Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act and the Veterans Employment Opportunity Act.
The Code of Federal Regulations
The Code of Federal Regulations, or CFR, codifies the rules published by executive departments and agencies in the Federal Register. Title 5 of the CFR, commonly referred to as 5 CFR, contains OPM's implementing regulations for federal HR law. The EEOC publishes its discrimination regulations at 29 CFR Part 1600. The CFR is updated annually and issued on a quarterly basis by the National Archives and Records Administration through the Office of the Federal Register.
Key 5 CFR sections for employee relations include 5 CFR 315.801 on probationary periods, 5 CFR 339 on medical issues, 5 CFR 430 on performance appraisals, 5 CFR 432 on performance-based reduction in grade and removal, 5 CFR 630 on leave, 5 CFR 752 on adverse actions, 5 CFR 771 on appeals, and 5 CFR 1200 on the Merit Systems Protection Board. For discrimination matters, 29 CFR 1600 covers EEOC regulations.
Discretionary Versus Non-Discretionary Provisions
One important distinction within the CFR is between discretionary and non-discretionary provisions. Where a regulation says an agency "must" do something, compliance is required. Where it says an agency "may" do something, the agency has discretion. This distinction affects how an agency interprets and applies regulatory requirements in individual cases.
For example, 5 CFR 430.208 is non-discretionary in requiring that a Level 1 summary rating of unacceptable be assigned if one or more critical elements are appraised as unacceptable. By contrast, 5 CFR 630.401 provides discretionary authority allowing an agency to require a medical certificate for absences exceeding three work days, or for shorter absences when the agency determines it to be necessary.
Agency Regulations
Agencies must follow their own regulations, not just federal statute and 5 CFR. This includes provisions in any applicable collective bargaining agreement. Failure to adhere to an agency's own rules can result in adverse findings in employee appeals cases. The case of Humphrey v. Department of the Army, decided September 26, 1997, illustrates this clearly. In that case, the Merit Systems Protection Board found that the agency failed to act in accordance with its own regulations on the treatment of employees with alcohol-related issues. Because the employee had complied with the agency's own rehabilitation requirements, a 31-day suspension was found to be the result of harmful error and could not stand.
This outcome underscores the importance of keeping agency regulations current, enforcing them consistently, and ensuring that HR professionals and supervisors are familiar with what those regulations require.
- Three titles of the U.S. Code govern federal HR matters: Title 5 for general human resources law, Title 29 for labor and discrimination law, and Title 38 for veterans employment provisions.
- Title 5 CFR contains OPM's implementing regulations and is a daily reference tool for federal HR professionals. Key sections cover probationary periods, performance, leave, adverse actions, appeals, and MSPB procedures.
- Non-discretionary regulatory provisions require agency compliance. Discretionary provisions allow agency judgment. Understanding the difference is essential for applying the regulations correctly.
- Agencies must follow their own regulations and those in applicable collective bargaining agreements. Failure to do so can result in harmful error findings in appeals proceedings.